Archived: Issue N1.14, 14 November 2026. Read the current issue.
The accountability rules are written. The public evidence is still thin.
This section is commentary by Broadhole. The facts in it link to their sources; the opinions, including the tone readings, are ours.
What moved
National news and opinion on NaRRA since the start of November, newest first. The items we found from 10 to 14 November were not negative (our reading). We found no new story naming NaRRA from 12 to 14 November; the items marked "recovery context" do not name NaRRA and are not counted below.
Each item has one tag for who is speaking (our reading, from its headline and outlet): Government (JIS, OPM, NaRRA, ministers), Opposition, Independent report (a news report with no single main voice), Opinion/editorial (columns, editorials, letters), International (IMF, UK, other foreign partners), Industry/civil society. A count is under Coverage by outlet.
- The Gleaner (recovery context, does not name NaRRA) Speaking: Government
ROOFS beneficiaries urged to use grants wiselyLabour Minister Pearnel Charles Jr. asks people receiving ROOFS home-repair grants to use them as intended. The grants are $75,000 for minor damage, $200,000 for major damage and up to $500,000 for severe damage, mostly for building materials.
- Nationwide 90FM (recovery context, does not name NaRRA) Speaking: Government
'Go mek a song of it!': PM vows to defend GOJ's Hurricane Melissa recovery effortsThe PM answers claims that hurricane relief money was misused and calls them false.
- The Gleaner (and Nationwide 90FM, 11 Nov) Speaking: Government
Holness eyes foreign labour for NaRRA · Nationwide report, 11 NovThe PM says NaRRA may need some skills from overseas because of a shortage of skilled workers and project managers. Our reading: mixed.
- Minister Robert Nesta Morgan, on X Speaking: Government
US team discusses technical assistance for NaRRAA team from the US Department of Commerce's Commercial Law Development Program and the US State Department met the minister about support to strengthen NaRRA's capacity.
- PM Andrew Holness, Instagram (recovery context, does not name NaRRA) Speaking: Government
The PM's own figures on hurricane assistanceClose to $12 billion spent and $9.6 billion more being sought. Of about 110,000 households assessed as needing support, just over 50,000 have received it; "many families are still waiting".
- The Gleaner and Irie FM; also Radio Jamaica, Nationwide 90FM, the Jamaica Observer and JIS (12 Nov) Speaking: International
IMF says Jamaica should speed up reconstruction, could cut debt faster · Irie FM report · Radio Jamaica report · Nationwide report · Observer report, 12 Nov · JIS report, 12 NovThe IMF's Article IV statement says NaRRA "provides an opportunity" and that procurement and contract management need work.
- Jamaica Observer, column by Keith Collister Speaking: Opinion/editorial
Breaking Jamaica's low growth cycleQuotes Senator Keith Duncan calling NaRRA "the implementation machine" and backing JAMRROC's oversight.
- CVM TV, Business News Speaking: Independent report
NaRRA: The new rules of engagement for developmentA business-news segment on NaRRA. We have not watched it; the tone is rated from the title only.
- Nationwide 90FM Speaking: Government
Local contractors to play major role in NaRRA reconstructionNaRRA's CEO says the UK deal will not sideline local contractors.
- JIS Speaking: Government
JIP seeks to partner with Gov't and NaRRA in post-Melissa reconstructionPlanners offer their support to the Government and NaRRA.
- The Gleaner Speaking: Government
Fit for the job: Gov't says no link between Morrison transfer, Holness sabotage claimsThe Opposition asks whether the transfer is linked to the PM's sabotage remarks or to NaRRA's powers under the FAA Act; the Government says there is no link.
- Nationwide 90FM Speaking: Government
NaRRA CEO defends himself amid criticism over salaryThe CEO's first public comment on his pay. He says more than 1,000 applications are being processed.
- The Gleaner, letter Speaking: Opinion/editorial
NaRRA vs ARCCA reader warns against repeating the mistakes of Peru's reconstruction authority, ARCC.
- The Gleaner and Jamaica Observer Speaking: International
Jamaica and UK sign deal to fast-track post-Melissa reconstruction · Observer reportA four-year partnership with a £10 million first-year programme. The firms named include Arup, Mace and Gleeds.
- Nationwide 90FM Speaking: Industry/civil society
JAMRROC to release data in defence of NaRRA CEO's salaryJAMRROC says it will publish salary data. See Still waiting on.
The baseline: March to November 2026
Our count of national coverage since NaRRA was announced, and the themes behind it.
News baseline: 35 national news and opinion items on NaRRA, March to November 2026
Coverage turned in October: 11 of 15 items negative, against 3 of 17 at launch. July to September was nearly silent outside government releases. Five of the 13 positive items came from JIS or OPM.
See all 35 items and sources
- PositiveSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 17/03 · Observer: Rebuilding Jamaica — faster, stronger, smarter
- NeutralSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 07/04 · Observer: What is NaRRA, and why does it matter?
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 16/04 · JIS: NaRRA procurement framework to ensure oversight and accountability
- NegativeSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 21/04 · Gleaner: Editorial: NaRRA needs further review
- NeutralSpeaking: Government 28/04 · Gleaner: PM to respond to concerns in NaRRA bill
- NeutralSpeaking: Independent report 29/04 · Gleaner: NaRRA bill clears House despite pushback from Opposition
- NeutralSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 30/04 · Observer: 20 changes for NaRRA
- PositiveSpeaking: Industry/civil society 01/05 · Gleaner: FLOW's Price backs NaRRA push to cut telecoms rollout delays
- PositiveSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 02/05 · Observer: Need for NaRRA
- PositiveSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 04/05 · Observer: NaRRA is the leadership Jamaica needs right now
- NeutralSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 06/05 · Observer: NaRRA requires a revolution to succeed
- NegativeSpeaking: Independent report 08/05 · Gleaner: Senate approves NaRRA bill amid continued oversight concerns
- NeutralSpeaking: Independent report 08/05 · Observer: Senate passes NaRRA Bill after marathon debate
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 27/05 · OPM: NaRRA Bill now law
- NeutralSpeaking: Government 04/06 · Observer: NaRRA CEO outlines priorities
- NegativeSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 05/06 · Observer: With all the best intentions for NaRRA...
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 10/06 · Gleaner: Four new courts to be constructed under NaRRA
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 16/07 · JIS: NaRRA CEO engages residents ahead of recovery effort in St Elizabeth
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 05/09 · JIS: NaRRA to begin review of Cabinet-referred projects
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 11/09 · JIS: JAMRROC to drive public engagement in reconstruction effort
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 06/10 · Gleaner: NaRRA examining major water infrastructure to address drought
- NegativeSpeaking: Opposition 06/10 · Observer: PNP questions NaRRA's $115m annual rent for waterfront headquarters
- NegativeSpeaking: Government 07/10 · Observer: Gov't scales back on NaRRA office
- NegativeSpeaking: Opposition 08/10 · Gleaner: Opposition cites law in push for public property to house NaRRA
- NegativeSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 09/10 · Gleaner: Editorial: the red NaRRA ledger
- NegativeSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 09/10 · Gleaner: Peter Espeut: Is NaRRA really here to help the West?
- NegativeSpeaking: Industry/civil society 11/10 · Jamaica Homes News: NaRRA under scrutiny as builders ask where the plan is
- NeutralSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 12/10 · Observer: Let's get NaRRA going
- NegativeSpeaking: Industry/civil society 14/10 · Observer: Civil society group livid over NaRRA spending
- NegativeSpeaking: Industry/civil society 14/10 · Gleaner: Builders: late government payments, not capacity, slowing reconstruction
- PositiveSpeaking: Government 15/10 · Gleaner: Government plans coastal protection project for Palisadoes
- PositiveSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 28/10 · Gleaner: Letter: FINSAC and NaRRA are not vote buyers
- NegativeSpeaking: Industry/civil society 30/10 · Gleaner: Builders push back: local experts reject skills deficit claims
- NegativeSpeaking: Opposition 30/10 · Gleaner: Golding blames Gov't's own non-performance for project delays
- NegativeSpeaking: Opinion/editorial 04/11 · Gleaner: Letter: NaRRA vs ARCC
Method: Broadhole coded the tone of each headline and summary found online (Gleaner, Observer, JIS, OPM, others), 17 March to 4 November 2026. Indicative, not a full media census. Social media is not included here; see On social. The November items listed above this chart are not part of the 35.
Coverage by outlet
This counts the tone of NaRRA stories in our sample (our reading). It is not a rating of any outlet's politics or quality.
| Outlet | Positive | Neutral | Negative | Total items |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Gleaner | 6 | 5 | 9 | 20 |
| Jamaica Observer | 5 | 7 | 4 | 16 |
| JIS | 6 | 0 | 0 | 6 |
| Nationwide 90FM | 1 | 4 | 0 | 5 |
| Other (fewer than 3 items each)CVM TV, Irie FM, Jamaica Homes News, Minister Morgan on X, OPM, Radio Jamaica: 1 each | Not broken down | 6 | ||
| All outlets | 20 | 19 | 14 | 53 |
Sample: 46 NaRRA stories on this page, 17 March to 12 November 2026: the 35 in the baseline and 11 more in What moved. The 4 November ARCC letter is in both lists and counts once. A story carried by more than one outlet counts once for each outlet, so the table counts 53 items.
Tone for the baseline comes from its labels. The What moved items are rated the same way, by what each item says (our reading): a Government or CEO statement defending NaRRA counts as Neutral, not Negative. Each outlet's version is rated on its own headline. Items marked "recovery context" do not name NaRRA and are not counted. Outlets with fewer than 3 items are grouped as Other and not broken down by tone.
| Tag | Stories |
|---|---|
| Government | 17 |
| Opinion/editorial | 14 |
| Industry/civil society | 6 |
| Independent report | 4 |
| Opposition | 3 |
| International | 2 |
| All stories | 46 |
Each story counts once here, whichever outlets carried it.
Spending
NegativeThe waterfront office lease and executive pay dominate coverage. The lease was scaled back to one floor after the outcry.
Delivery
NegativeCommentators say reconstruction is behind comparable programmes and the register shows little yet.
Governance
NegativeCritics say power is concentrated and safeguards are weak. The oversight that exists is not well explained.
Contractors
NegativeBuilders say late government payments, not lack of capacity, slow the work.
Communities
PositiveThe CEO's community visits and calls for local jobs drew positive coverage.
Oversight
NeutralJAMRROC has pledged public reports on tendering, timelines and budgets.
Themes from national news and commentary, May to November 2026; tone labels are our reading. Sources below.
At a glance
The project we are following
We follow one project closely so far. Its full history is on the Palisadoes project page.
| Project | Parish | Stage | Latest | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Palisadoes and Port Royal coastal protection About 14.2 km of coastline: revetments, dunes and mangroves, road sections, coastal monitoring. $56 million (currency not stated in the report) | Kingston | Proposed | Cabinet approved it for NaRRA's work programme; funding expected from NaRRA's project pool. No start or completion date announced. Open the project page → | Gleaner, 15 Oct 2026 |
On the ground at the Palisadoes
Footage from the Palisadoes, filmed in November 2026. The clips show the coastline as it was in November.
See the full project timeline on the Palisadoes project page.
Still waiting on
Things that have been promised or would help the public follow the work, and that we could not find as of 14 November 2026. We will check them again in the next issue.
JAMRROC's salary data Unverified
JAMRROC said on 2 November it would release data in defence of the CEO's salary (Nationwide, 2 Nov). We found no sign it has been published.
A public register of approved projects, with entries Unverified
The Government listed a public electronic register of approved projects among NaRRA's oversight tools (OPM, 27 May), and NaRRA is to keep one (JIS, 16 Apr). We found no register with entries.
An official NaRRA social media channel Unverified
We found no official NaRRA account on the main social platforms. Most of the NaRRA video titles we found on YouTube are critical.
Start and finish dates for the Palisadoes project
No start or completion date had been announced when the project was reported (Gleaner, 15 Oct).
Ask a question
Ask about NaRRA or the Palisadoes project. The assistant answers only from the published government and press sources we have collected, and names its source. If it has no source, it says so. It is run by Broadhole, not by NaRRA.
Get the next issue
Sign up for the Broadhole email newsletter to get future issues of this update. No spam. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Where the facts come from
The news items above link to their own sources. These are the main sources for the commentary, figures and project details.
- OPM: NaRRA Bill now law
- JIS: Anderson appointed NaRRA CEO
- JIS: NaRRA active on the ground
- JIS: NaRRA procurement framework
- JIS: JAMRROC to drive public engagement
- JIS: US$5 million grant for the reconstruction programme, September 2026
- Gleaner: NaRRA bill clears House, 29 April 2026
- Observer: Melissa cost estimate (PIOJ), 4 March 2026
- Gleaner editorial, 9 October 2026
- Gleaner, 30 October 2026
- Gleaner: builders on late payments, 14 October 2026
- Gleaner letter, 4 November 2026
- Observer: What is NaRRA
- Gleaner: Palisadoes coastal protection plan, 15 October 2026
- Observer: questions over NaRRA's annual rent, 6 October 2026
- Observer: Government scales back NaRRA office
- Nationwide: JAMRROC head blames poor communication, 28 October 2026
- Nationwide: NaRRA CEO on his salary, 4 November 2026
- Irie FM: IMF on reconstruction, 11 November 2026
- Radio Jamaica: IMF urges Jamaica to speed up post-Melissa reconstruction, 11 November 2026
- Nationwide: IMF says Jamaica still on path to recovery but risks remain, 11 November 2026
- Observer: Keep spending tight (IMF statement), 12 November 2026
- JIS: IMF praises Jamaica's resilience and policy frameworks after Hurricane Melissa, 12 November 2026
- Gleaner: Holness eyes foreign labour for NaRRA, 12 November 2026
- CVM TV Business News: NaRRA, the new rules of engagement for development, 11 November 2026
- Minister Robert Nesta Morgan on X: US technical assistance for NaRRA, 11 November 2026
- PM Andrew Holness, Instagram: hurricane assistance figures, 11 November 2026
- Gleaner: ROOFS beneficiaries urged to use grants wisely, 12 November 2026
- Nationwide: PM vows to defend GOJ's Hurricane Melissa recovery efforts, 12 November 2026
- Nationwide: PM says lack of skilled labour threatens large-scale projects, 11 November 2026
What is going well
The NaRRA law passed with safeguards added in the House: consultations with affected residents, a report from the CEO every six months that is tabled in Parliament, and conflict-of-interest rules (Gleaner, 29 Apr). JAMRROC, the independent oversight committee, launched in September and pledged public reports on tendering, timelines and budgets (JIS, 11 Sep). Help is arriving: a US$5 million EU grant, through the World Bank, for NaRRA's planning, procurement and contract management (JIS, Sep), and a four-year partnership with the United Kingdom signed on 3 November (Gleaner, 3 Nov). On 11 November the IMF said NaRRA "provides an opportunity" (Irie FM, 11 Nov).
What is not going well
Coverage turned in October: 11 of the 15 national news and opinion items we found were negative (our reading; method below). Much of it was about spending, led by the J$115 million yearly office lease, which was later scaled back (Observer, 7 Oct). Early November added criticism of the CEO's salary (Nationwide, 4 Nov). Builders say late government payments, not a lack of capacity, are slowing the work (Gleaner, 14 Oct). The IMF named procurement and contract management as areas that need work (Irie FM, 11 Nov). The public register of approved projects that the Government promised (OPM, 27 May) has no entries that we could find.
Our view
Two problems are getting mixed together. One is delivery: procurement, contracts and payments, which the IMF and the builders point to. Both sides of the delivery debate are now on record: the Prime Minister says a shortage of skilled workers and project managers limits delivery (Gleaner, 12 Nov), while builders blamed late government payments (Gleaner, 14 Oct). Only the people doing the work can fix that, and it will take time. The other is information. JAMRROC's own chair blamed the controversy on poor communication: "without facts, people are left to speculate" (Nationwide, 28 Oct). That part can improve sooner, as the promised items appear. We list them under Still waiting on and will check them in each issue.